Creative Fatigue Detection | Marketing Automation

Back to Case Studies
Marketing

Ad Creative Performance & Fatigue Detection System

AI-powered creative performance analysis with fatigue detection, winning theme identification, and optimization recommendations.

Marketing automation case study featuring ai implementation and reporting.

+27%

Performance Improvement

Shortened

Testing Cycles

Significantly Reduced

Wasteful Spend

Overview

A performance marketing team struggled with creative fatigue, poor insights on what themes worked, and a lack of consolidated creative performance data. Performance improved by 27%+ with shortened testing cycles.

Business Context

The performance marketing team managed thousands of ad creatives across Meta, TikTok, and YouTube, spending significant budget monthly across these platforms. However, they had no systematic way to understand which creative elements actually drove performance. Different team members had contradictory opinions about what worked, agencies delivered creatives based on intuition rather than data, and creative fatigue was only detected after performance had already cratered. The team was wasting substantial spend on underperforming creatives while potentially effective concepts were never properly tested. Creative decisions were made based on preferences and past experience rather than current data-driven insights.

How We Built It

We built a creative intelligence platform that ingests performance data from all advertising platform APIs, capturing spend, impressions, clicks, conversions, and engagement metrics at the individual creative level. The system indexes every creative's visual elements, text copy, hooks, calls-to-action, and audience targeting using AI analysis. Computer vision extracts visual features — colors, faces, text overlays, product prominence, scene types — while NLP processes copy for tone, length, value propositions, and urgency signals. The creative intelligence engine correlates these creative characteristics with performance outcomes, identifying which themes, hooks, and visual styles drive the strongest engagement and conversion rates. Fatigue detection algorithms analyze performance decay curves, alerting the team when creatives are losing effectiveness before performance drops significantly. The system identifies similarity clusters of creatives that may be cannibalizing each other's performance, recommending which to pause when audiences overlap. The creative wall UI provides a visual interface where the team can browse all creatives with auto-generated tags, filter by performance metrics, and view trend charts showing performance trajectories over time. Automated reports summarize creative performance weekly with actionable recommendations for optimization and refresh priorities. A/B test results are automatically analyzed and winning variants are flagged for scaling across additional audiences.

Challenges

1

Thousands of creatives across Meta, TikTok, YouTube

2

No unified metrics across platforms

3

Creative fatigue detection manual and inconsistent

4

No system to identify winning hooks/themes

5

Agencies delivering inconsistent reporting

What We Delivered

Creative data ingestion from all ad platform APIs

Indexed text, visuals, hooks, and audience segments

Creative intelligence engine identifying outperforming themes

Fatigue detection based on decay curves

Similarity clusters of cannibalized creatives

Creative wall UI with auto-tagging and trend charts

Tech Stack

Creative data ingestion via APIs, Indexed text/visuals/hooks, Engagement → conversion correlation, Fatigue detection, Next.js UI

Tags

MarketingAI ImplementationReportingIntegrationOpenAIMake.comRetoolAI AutomationWorkflow Automation

Results

+27%

Performance Improvement

Shortened

Testing Cycles

Significantly Reduced

Wasteful Spend

Strategic Impact

The 27% performance improvement came from two sources: quickly identifying and scaling winning creative concepts, and rapidly deprecating underperformers before they wasted budget. Testing cycles shortened dramatically because the team could now see within days rather than weeks whether a creative concept was working. Creative fatigue detection has proven transformational — the team now refreshes creatives proactively rather than reactively, maintaining performance levels that previously would have decayed. The data-driven insights have changed how the team briefs agencies, with specific guidance on hooks, visual styles, and copy approaches that have proven effective. Wasteful spend on underperforming creatives dropped significantly as the system flags poor performers quickly and recommends reallocation. The similarity clustering revealed that the team had been running multiple creatives that competed with each other for the same audiences, leading to a more diverse creative strategy. Agency relationships improved because performance discussions are now grounded in data rather than subjective opinions. The creative intelligence has revealed surprising insights — certain visual elements and hook structures that the team assumed would work poorly actually drove strong performance when tested. The platform has become the foundation for creative strategy meetings, replacing opinion-based discussions with data-driven analysis. Knowledge about what works no longer lives only in individual team members' heads but is captured systematically in the platform. New team members ramp up faster because institutional knowledge about creative performance is accessible and documented.

Want Similar Results?

Let's discuss how we can transform your operations with automation and AI.

Book a Strategy Call
Related Case Studies